Koleston, Igora, Majirel, Nook or Alfaparf: Which Professional Hair Dye do you choose and why
There is no single “best” professional hair dye for everyone: Koleston Perfect and Igora Royal are mixed 1:1 and offer the widest shade ranges, Majirel and Alfaparf Evolution of the Color use a 1:1.5 ratio, while Nook focuses on organic farming ingredients and ammonia-free options. Choose based on the percentage of white hair, the desired shade, and the developer you already have.
Updated: November 20, 2026 · Author: Berta Varga
In short
- For over 50% white hair, all five ranges have natural shades designed for coverage; Igora Royal claims 100% coverage on natural shades up to level 9, while Majirel requires mixing with a natural base.
- Mixing ratios vary: 1:1 for Koleston Perfect and Igora Royal, 1:1.5 for Majirel and Alfaparf Evolution of the Color. Do not switch developers between brands without checking the technical data sheet.
- On probeauty.ro, you can find Koleston Perfect ME+, Igora Royal, Majirel, and Nook; Alfaparf hair dye is not sold in the store, as we only carry the Alfaparf care range.
- At the time of update, a 60 ml tube usually costs between 37.95 and 55 lei for Koleston and Igora, and 69 lei for Majirel; the 100 ml Nook tube costs around 64 lei.
- Regardless of the brand, a sensitivity test before dyeing remains mandatory.
What Criteria Do You Use to Compare Two Professional Hair Dyes?
Short answer: you compare three things, in this order: how well it covers white hair, how the shade range is structured, and what developer and mixing ratio it requires. The price per tube only matters after that, because a different mixing ratio changes the amount of product used in one application.
All the dyes in this comparison are permanent oxidative dyes. The European Commission describes them as the third category of hair dyes, based on resistance, and shows that they make up the largest part of the European coloring market (European Commission, hair coloring products). In short, an oxidative dye requires three components:
- color precursors, which penetrate the hair shaft;
- couplers, which determine the shade;
- an oxidant, usually hydrogen peroxide, in an alkaline environment (ammonia or an alternative), which opens the cuticle and triggers the reaction.
Because they all work on the same principle, the real differences lie in the formula, the shade range, and the developer system.
White Hair Coverage
Manufacturers use different formulations for the same purpose, and the shade difference in the text matters. What to look for in the technical data sheet:
- the stated percentage (“up to 100%” or “100%”) and which series it applies to: usually natural shades, not fashion shades;
- whether the brand requires mixing with a natural shade for over a certain percentage of white hair;
- what developer concentration it recommends for coverage (usually 6%, or 20 vol);
- whether there is a series dedicated to mature hair, such as Igora Royal Absolutes.
Shade Range and Numbering System
The first number in the code almost everywhere indicates the level of lightness (from 1, black, to 10 or 12, very light blonde), while the numbers after the separator indicate the reflection. The separator varies:
- Wella uses a slash: 7/1, where 7 is the level, 1 is the primary reflection, and a second number is the secondary reflection;
- Schwarzkopf uses a hyphen: 6-00, 7-1;
- L’Oréal, Nook, and Alfaparf use a dot: 7.1, 9.13, 6.23.
Note: the same number does not mean the same reflection across all brands. At Wella, /1 is ash and /7 is brown, but a number taken from one brand does not automatically translate to the code of another. When switching from one brand to another, compare the shade in the color catalog, not the code.
Developer and Mixing Ratio
The mixing ratio tells you how many milliliters of developer to add per gram of dye. The two systems found in this comparison are:
- 1:1, for example 60 g of dye and 60 ml of developer (Koleston Perfect, Igora Royal);
- 1:1.5, for example 60 g of dye and 90 ml of developer (Majirel, Alfaparf Evolution of the Color);
- 1:2 for special blonde or high-lift series, across almost all brands.
The developer concentration determines how much it lightens the color: 3% only deposits pigment, 6% lightens one level and covers white, 9% and 12% lighten two to three levels.
Comparison Table: Koleston, Igora, Majirel, Nook, and Alfaparf
Short answer: Koleston and Igora have the largest shade ranges and a 1:1 mixing ratio, Majirel and Alfaparf use 1:1.5 with a 35-minute processing time, while Nook comes in a 100 ml tube, with an ammonia-free option. The technical data is taken from the official websites, and the prices are from the probeauty.ro catalog at the time of update.
| Range | White Hair Coverage | Shade Range and Numbering | Developer and Mixing Ratio | Price per Tube (probeauty.ro, at the Time of Update) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wella Koleston Perfect ME+ | Up to 100% | Over 140 shades, code 7/1 (level/primary and secondary reflection) | Welloxon Perfect 4%, 6%, 9%, 12% (plus 1.9% for pastel); 1:1, Special Blonde 1:2; 30 to 40 minutes without heat | 60 ml tube: from 34 lei, most shades between 40 and 55 lei |
| Schwarzkopf Igora Royal | 100% on natural shades up to level 9; up to 70% on fashion shades | 143 shades, code 6-00 (level-reflection) | Igora Royal Oil Developer 3%, 6%, 9%, 12%; 1:1, Highlifts 12- 1:2; 30 to 45 minutes | 60 ml tube: most shades between 37.95 and 43.95 lei |
| L’Oréal Professionnel Majirel | Up to 100%; over 50% white, half the desired shade, half natural base | Code 7.1 (level.reflection); 60 shades in the probeauty.ro catalog | Oxydant Crème 12.5, 20, 30 vol (40 vol only for Highlift); 1:1.5; 35 minutes | 60 ml tube: 69 lei, the same price for all shades |
| Nook The Origin Color and The Virgin Color | “Perfect coverage” of white hair, without a stated percentage; Virgin is positioned for the first white hairs | The Origin: 103 shades, The Virgin: 87 shades; code 7.1 | The Service Color Activator 1.5%, 3%, 6%, 9%, 12%; the ratio is not published on the official website, follow the instructions on the box | 100 ml tube: most shades between 61.60 and 64.96 lei |
| Alfaparf Milano Evolution of the Color | 100% on natural series (Naturali, NB, NI) | Code 6.23 (level.reflection), official shade chart | Oxid’o 10, 20, 30, 40 vol; 1:1.5, Platinum 1:2; 35 minutes | Not sold on probeauty.ro (market benchmark) |
A few notes to help you read the table correctly:
- the Nook tube is 100 ml, the others are 60 ml, so the price per tube cannot be compared directly;
- at a 1:1.5 ratio, you use more developer per application, so also take into account the price of the developer bottle;
- some shades in the catalog are temporarily discounted, which is why we give the range in which most shades fall, not just the minimum.
Wella Koleston Perfect: Where Does It Rank?
Short answer: Koleston Perfect ME+ is the best choice when you want a very wide range of shades, including natural shades, intense reds, and special blondes, and you already work with Welloxon Perfect developers in a 1:1 ratio.
Wella describes the range as having over 140 shades, with up to 100% coverage of white hair (Wella Professionals, Koleston Perfect). The code has three parts: the level, the primary reflection, and the secondary reflection, for example 4/71. The official usage guide explains the reflection table: /1 ash, /2 matte, /3 gold, /4 red, /5 mahogany, /6 violet, /7 brown, /8 pearl, /9 cendré (Koleston Perfect usage guide).
What sets it apart:
- ME+ technology, which Wella presents as the molecule that replaces PTD and PPD and reduces the risk of developing a new dye allergy; however, the technical data sheet specifies that the risk of an allergic reaction, even a severe one, remains;
- ME+ is only present in certain shades in the Pure Naturals, Rich Naturals, Vibrant Reds, Special Blonde, and Deep Browns series, not throughout the entire range;
- the processing time is 30 to 40 minutes without heat, while the Special Blonde series lasts longer and is mixed 1:2;
- 6% developer lightens one level and covers white, 9% lightens two levels, 12% three levels.
It is not the right choice if you work with a developer from another brand and do not want to change the system. The 1:1 ratio and Welloxon concentrations are calibrated for the Koleston formula. In the store, you can find Koleston Perfect ME+ 60 ml, Welloxon Perfect 6% 20 vol developer, and the rest of the range in the Wella Color collection.
Schwarzkopf Igora Royal: What Type of Hair Is It For?
Short answer: Igora Royal is especially suitable for hair with a lot of white, thanks to the natural shades with 100% stated coverage up to level 9 and the Absolutes series for mature hair. It is mixed 1:1 with Igora Royal Oil Developer.
Schwarzkopf Professional presents Igora Royal as a range of 143 shades, from natural shades with 100% coverage to fashion shades with up to 70% coverage. In the code, the number before the hyphen indicates the level, while the numbers after the hyphen indicate the primary and secondary reflections.
What type of hair does it work well on:
- hair with over 50% white hairs, on the natural double-zero shades (6-00, 7-00), which have extra natural pigment;
- mature hair, with the Igora Royal Absolutes series, for which the brand claims up to 100% coverage, a 1:1 mix with 9% developer, and 30 to 45 minutes of processing time; for over 90% white, it recommends 6% (Igora Royal Absolutes);
- natural hair from level 6 and up that needs to be lightened significantly, with the Highlifts series: the 10- series lifts up to 4 levels on a level 7 base, while the 12- series lifts up to 5 levels, in a 1:2 ratio (Igora Royal Highlifts).
It is not the right choice if you want a short processing time. The technical manual indicates 30 to 45 minutes, not 30. For refreshing lengths, the Igora Vibrance demi-permanent option is gentler. The products are in the Schwarzkopf Professional Igora collection, including Igora Royal 60 ml and Igora Royal Oil Developer 6% 20 vol.
L’Oréal Majirel, Nook, and Alfaparf
Short answer: Majirel and Alfaparf Evolution of the Color have the same 1:1.5 ratio and 35-minute processing time, while Nook is the choice for those who want organic farming ingredients and an ammonia-free option. Majirel and Nook are available on probeauty.ro; Alfaparf hair dye is not.
Majirel and Shade Fidelity
Majirel is the classic permanent dye from L’Oréal Professionnel. The brand claims up to 100% coverage of white hair and a 60 ml tube mixed with 90 ml of Oxydant, meaning a 1:1.5 ratio, with 35 minutes of processing time.
What you need to know before the first application:
- for under 50% white hair, use only the desired shade; between 50% and 100%, mix half the desired shade with half natural base;
- 12.5 vol developer lightens one level to one and a half levels, 20 vol two levels, 30 vol three levels;
- 40 vol (12%) developer is only used with Majirel Highlift, for a lightening of 4 to 4.5 levels;
- the formula contains Ionène G and the Incell complex, which the brand associates with better-conditioned and shinier hair.
Majirel is sold on probeauty.ro: Majirel 60 ml, Majirel Cool Cover 60 ml for cool reflections, and Oxydant Crème 6% 20 vol. The entire range is in the L’Oréal Professionnel collection. It is not the right choice if you already have a large stock of 1:1 developer from another brand, because Majirel requires its own Oxydant.
Nook, the Organic Ingredient Option
Nook is an Italian brand with two oxidative permanent dyes. The exact formulation matters: Nook does not call the dye “organic,” but says that the formulas contain ingredients from organic farming. No percentage of natural ingredients or certifying body appears on the official website.
- The Origin Color: 103 shades in a 100 ml tube, “perfect” coverage of white hair, lightening of up to 4 tones with the super blonde series, without PPD and without added resorcinol, vegan formula, with quinoa protein and organic Abyssinian oil;
- The Virgin Color: 87 shades in a 100 ml tube, 0% ammonia, without PPD and without added resorcinol, with organic plant extracts; the brand recommends it for the first white hairs;
- The Service Color Activator: the dedicated developer, in five concentrations, from 5 vol (1.5%) to 40 vol (12%).
On probeauty.ro, you can find Nook The Origin Color, Nook The Virgin Color, and the 6% 20 vol activator, all in the Nook hair dye collection. It is not the right choice if you have over 50% resistant white hair and want a guarantee expressed in percentages; Nook does not publish a coverage percentage. Details on what “ammonia-free” means can be found in the article about professional ammonia-free dyes.
Alfaparf and the Surrounding Care Range
Alfaparf Milano Evolution of the Color is a market benchmark, not a product in our catalog: at the time of update, Alfaparf hair dye is not sold on probeauty.ro. We include it because many hairstylists compare it with the other four. Official data:
- 100% coverage of white hair on the natural series, 1:1.5 ratio (60 g dye and 90 ml developer), and 35 minutes of processing time, according to the official shade chart;
- the Platinum series is mixed 1:2 with 40 vol developer and lasts 55 minutes;
- Color Guard technology, with hyaluronic acid, which the brand associates with color protection against blue and UV light, vegan formula;
- Oxid’o developer comes in 5, 10, 20, 30, and 40 vol.
What you can find from Alfaparf on probeauty.ro is the post-dye care range: Semi di Lino shampoos and masks, including anti-yellow options for blondes and anti-orange options for brunettes, in the Alfaparf collection. You can use them after any of the dyes above.
Which Hair Dye Should You Choose if You Work in a Salon Versus at Home?
Short answer: in the salon, you choose the range with the palette and special series you need daily and stick to a single developer system. At home, you choose the natural shade closest to your color, with 6% developer, and follow the brand's mixing ratio exactly.
For the salon, the practical criteria are:
- palette: Koleston Perfect and Igora Royal cover most needs from a single system, from natural to special blonde and intense red;
- clients with a lot of white: Igora Royal Absolutes or Majirel with a natural base mix;
- clients who ask for ammonia-free formulas or those with organic farming ingredients: Nook The Virgin Color;
- color catalogs: keep them for each range you use, so you can compare shades on strands, not codes.
For home use, the rules are stricter because you do not have a colorist next to you:
- choose a shade within three tones of your natural color;
- use the developer from the same brand as the dye, at a concentration of 6% for covering white;
- weigh the dye and measure the developer, do not estimate by eye;
- respect the processing time in the technical data sheet; if you extend it, the color will not darken further, it will only increase the stress on the hair shaft.
Safety is the same in the salon and at home. The FDA recommends a sensitivity test on the skin before each dyeing and mentions PPD among the ingredients most commonly associated with allergic reactions, the NHS recommends testing the dye at least 48 hours before application.
- If you have ever had itching, redness, or swelling after dyeing, do not repeat the application and seek the advice of a dermatologist before trying another dye.
- Formulas without added PPD or with ME+ do not completely exclude the risk of allergy, and manufacturers state this explicitly.
After dyeing, the color lasts longer with a shampoo for color-treated hair and a suitable mask; you can find options in the Kérastase collection, and for detangling without pulling on freshly dyed hair, brushes in the Olivia Garden collection. All the dyes compared here, plus other brands, are in the hair dyes collection, and the developers separately, in the developers collection.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which professional dye is the best?
There isn't just one. For a wide palette and a 1:1 mix, choose Koleston Perfect or Igora Royal; for hair with a lot of white, Igora Royal or Majirel with a natural base; and for ammonia-free formulas, Nook The Virgin Color. First, compare the coverage on white hair, then the palette and developer, and only at the end, the price.
Koleston or Igora?
Both are mixed 1:1 and have over 140 shades. Igora Royal claims 100% coverage of white hair on natural shades up to level 9 and has the Absolutes series for mature hair. Koleston Perfect claims coverage of up to 100% and has ME+ technology in certain shades. Choose the range whose developer you already use.
What do you think about Majirel dye?
Majirel is a permanent dye with a claimed coverage of up to 100% of white hair, 60 ml tube, 1:1.5 ratio with Oxydant Crème, and 35 minutes of processing time. For over 50% white, half is mixed with a natural base. On probeauty.ro, the tube costs 69 lei as of the update, for all shades.
Which dye covers white hair best?
According to official data, Igora Royal (100% on natural shades up to level 9), Alfaparf Evolution of the Color (100% on natural series), Koleston Perfect, and Majirel (up to 100%). The result also depends on the technique: natural shade, 6% developer, and full processing time.
Which developer works with Igora Royal?
Igora Royal Oil Developer, in a 1:1 ratio. Use 3% for color deposit, 6% for white coverage and one level of lift, 9% for two levels, and 12% only with the special blonde series. The processing time is from 30 to 45 minutes.
Is Nook an organic dye?
Not in the sense of a certification. Nook says that The Origin Color and The Virgin Color contain ingredients from organic farming, without added PPD and resorcinol, and that The Virgin Color does not contain ammonia. The official website does not indicate a percentage of natural ingredients or any certification body.
Share
